Foundations · Calculators · 7 min read
Two Vedic astrology calculators give different answers for the same birth details because each one is built on a set of choices: the ayanāṁśa, the node, the seven or eight kāraka scheme, the method for each divisional chart and how a daśā year is counted. This page lists those choices in one table, and says which ones the Tantric Astro calculators use.
Different Vedic astrology calculators give different answers because they use different settings for the same chart, and a planet or lagna sitting near a boundary will fall on the other side of it when the setting changes. Your birth data is the same. What changes is the ayanāṁśa, Rāhu’s position, the kāraka scheme, the rule used to cast a divisional chart, and sometimes the birth time itself by a minute or two. Many people on Reddit ask this after getting one ātmakāraka from one app and another from the next, or a different Iṣṭa Devatā, or a different D60 sign. In most cases neither app is broken. They are answering slightly different questions.
The settings that change the answer
Here are the choices that most often move a result, and what the Tantric Astro calculators use for each. All of them run in your browser, in the True Citrapakṣa ayanāṁśa, and where a choice is open they follow Jagannātha Horā’s default, with Parāśara’s text for the divisional charts.
| Setting | The usual choices | What it changes | What Tantric Astro’s calculators use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ayanāṁśa | Many apps let you choose among several, or default to one without saying so | Every sidereal longitude, so the lagna, any planet near a sign edge, the nakṣatra and every varga | True Citrapakṣa, with Spica at 0° Libra |
| Rāhu and Ketu | Mean node or true node | Rāhu’s and Ketu’s degree, so Rāhu’s rank as a kāraka and his divisional signs | Mean node, as in Jagannātha Horā unless you change it; you can switch to the true node |
| Chara kāraka scheme | Seven kārakas (Sun to Saturn) or eight (with Rāhu) | Which graha is the ātmakāraka, and so the kārakāṁśa and the Iṣṭa Devatā; with seven there is no pitṛkāraka | Eight, with Rāhu, as in Jagannātha Horā; you can leave him out |
| Rāhu’s degrees | Counted from the start of the sign, or from the end | Whether Rāhu becomes the ātmakāraka | 30° less his longitude in the sign, as the Sudhā commentary on Bṛhat Parāśara Horā Śāstra 32.13 says |
| Chart for the kārakāṁśa | Navāṁśa (D9) or vimśāṁśa (D20) | The 12th from the kārakāṁśa, and so the Iṣṭa Devatā | D9 by default, D20 as an option in the Iṣṭa Devatā calculator |
| An empty 12th from the kārakāṁśa | Go straight to its lord, or first see which grahas aspect it by rāśi dṛṣṭi | The graha that decides the deity | Rāśi dṛṣṭi first, the lord only when nothing occupies or aspects it |
| D16, D24 and D30 | Software such as PyJHora offers alternatives: parivṛtti variants and different counting for even signs | The divisional sign of a planet or the lagna | Parāśara’s text |
| D60 sign | Counted from Aries (R. Santhanam’s reading of Bṛhat Parāśara Horā Śāstra 6.33) or from the sign itself (Jagannātha Horā) | The D60 sign only; the deity of the part is the same either way | From the sign itself, as in Jagannātha Horā |
| Houses | Whole signs, or a house system with cusps | Which house a planet is said to occupy | Whole signs from the lagna |
| Daśā year | Different year lengths | The start and end dates of every daśā | The sidereal year, from one entry of the Sun into Aries to the next, as in Jagannātha Horā |
| Birth time | As recorded, rounded, or rectified | The lagna and every divisional lagna; the higher the varga, the more it matters | Exactly what you enter; the D9, D10 and D20 calculators show how close the lagna is to the next part |
Why is my atmakaraka different on another calculator?
Usually because one calculator counts seven chara kārakas and the other counts eight. Parāśara gives both: seven, from the Sun to Saturn, or eight, ending with Rāhu. With Rāhu, his degrees are taken from the end of the sign, because he moves backwards, so Rāhu at 2° of a sign counts as 28°, and then he is usually the ātmakāraka. Leave him out and the graha with the most degrees among the other seven takes the role. In Śrī Rāmakṛṣṇa’s chart the two schemes give two different ātmakārakas, as I have worked in how to find your Iṣṭa Devatā.
The second cause is the node. Mean and true node put Rāhu at slightly different degrees, and when he is close to another graha in degrees, the order can flip. The atmakaraka calculator tells you which scheme and which node it used, under the result, so you can match it to the other app before comparing.
Why is my Ishta Devata different?
Three choices sit between your ātmakāraka and your deity, and apps make them silently. First, the scheme above, which can change the ātmakāraka itself. Second, the chart the kārakāṁśa is read in. Most of us were taught the navāṁśa, but Parāśara gives the vimśāṁśa for upāsanā, Bṛhat Parāśara Horā Śāstra 7.4, and the D20 can name a different deity. Third, what to do when the 12th from the kārakāṁśa is empty. Many calculators go straight to its lord. Before the lord, the grahas that aspect that sign by rāśi dṛṣṭi have to be seen, and they often decide it. The ishta devata calculator does it in that order, in the D9 or the D20.
Does the ayanāṁśa change my lagna?
It can. Every ayanāṁśa is a different starting point for the sidereal zodiac, so changing it shifts the lagna and every planet by the same amount. If your lagna is in the middle of a sign, a different ayanāṁśa will not move it. If it is in the first or last degree or two of a sign, it may cross into the next one, and then every house changes with it. The same goes for a planet near a sign edge, and for your nakṣatra, which also decides your first Vimśottarī daśā and its balance.
So before comparing two charts, check that both use the same ayanāṁśa. Many apps let you choose it in their settings. Ours use True Citrapakṣa throughout.
Why does one planet land in a different divisional sign?
Even with the same ayanāṁśa, two programs can differ by about 0.01° on a planet’s longitude. That is nothing in the rāśi chart. But a divisional chart cuts each sign into small parts, and a planet that close to the edge of a part can land in a different divisional sign. While testing our calculators we saw exactly this: a Sun at 330.005° in one program and 329.995° in another, which is the line between Aquarius and Pisces. The divisional signs built on it can change with it.
The other cause is method. For the D16, D24 and D30, software such as PyJHora offers alternative methods, parivṛtti variants and different counting for even signs. Our calculators follow Parāśara’s text for these. If your other app has a varga method setting, check it first.
Why does the D60 change with a few minutes of birth time?
Because each D60 part is only half a degree wide. The lagna moves about 1° every 4 minutes, so it passes through one D60 part in about 2 minutes of clock time. For comparison, it takes about six minutes to cross a D20 aṁśa and about thirteen minutes on average to cross a navāṁśa. A birth time rounded to the nearest five minutes is fine for the rāśi chart and usually for the D9, but it cannot fix your D60 lagna. The higher the varga, the more the birth time matters.
There is also a counting difference in the D60 sign itself. R. Santhanam’s reading of Bṛhat Parāśara Horā Śāstra 6.33 counts it from Aries, while Jagannātha Horā counts from the sign the planet is in. The deity of the part is the same either way, so if you are reading the D60 deity, this one does not matter. The ashtakavarga calculator casts any varga up to the D60, counted from the sign itself.
Why are my dasha dates a few days or months off?
Three things move them: the ayanāṁśa, the length of a daśā year, and the birth time, because the Moon’s exact degree sets how much of the first daśā was already spent at birth. A small change in the Moon’s degree shifts every date that follows. Our Vimshottari dasha calculator uses the sidereal year, from one entry of the Sun into Aries to the next, which is what Jagannātha Horā uses unless you change it.
Which one is right?
Each setting is a reading of the texts, and some of them, like the seven or eight kārakas, are given side by side by Parāśara himself. What matters is that you know which choice gave your answer, and that you read your chart with one consistent set. When two apps disagree, line up the settings in the table above one by one, and the difference will almost always come from one of them. Where your result sits right on a boundary, look at both answers, the way you would read the neighbouring aṁśa when the birth time is uncertain.
If your chart sits on a boundary. A calculator can only give you one side of the line. When your lagna or ātmakāraka is that close, the chart needs to be read with the birth time checked against events. That is what a Practical Prediction consultation does, and a Spiritual Guidance consultation reads the deity question in the D9 and the D20 together.
Questions people ask
Is it a bug if two apps show different results?
Usually not. Most differences come from a setting: ayanāṁśa, node, kāraka scheme, varga method or daśā year. Match those first. If the rāśi positions still differ by more than a small fraction of a degree, check the birth time and time zone you entered.
Do the Tantric Astro calculators store my birth data?
No. They calculate in your browser, and nothing you enter leaves it.
Sources: Bṛhat Parāśara Horā Śāstra 6.33, 7.4, 32.1, 32.5 and 32.13, Chaukhamba edition with the Sudhā commentary and R. Santhanam’s translation; Jaimini, Upadeśa Sūtra 1.1.2-4. Full details on sources and editions.